MAGGIE’S PLAN (2016), a new comedy drama by writer/director Rebecca Miller, has a lot to say about relationships, so much so that its story is richer in its poignacy than in its comedy.
Maggie (Greta Gerwig) is a young a career advisor for art and design students, and when the movie opens, she laments that she can never seem to remain in a relationship for more than six months. She tells her friend Tony (Bill Hader) of her plan to have a baby and raise it on her own without the help of a father. She has a plan because that’s what Maggie does- plan for everything. She’s arranged for one of their college friends, Guy (Travis Fimmel) to provide his sperm so she can artificially inseminate herself. Tony is none too happy about this because he remembers Guy as a weird math major in college, but Maggie assures him that Guy is fine, as he is now a successful pickle entrepeneur.
Maggie’s plan gets derailed when she meets John Harding (Ethan Hawke) an adjunct professor at the college, and the two hit it off immediately, especially since John is having a difficult time with his marriage, having to deal with his domineering wife Georgette (Julianne Moore) who’s a professor at Columbia University. John feels trapped in the marriage, as Georgette is so focused on her career, he has to take a back seat with his, plus raise their two children pretty much on his own, and as such he cannot write the novel he’s always wanted to write.
Besides falling in love with John, Maggie also sees herself as being able to rescue him from his manipulating wife. Since John has fallen in love with Maggie as well, he divorces Georgette and marries Maggie. They have a daughter, John can now work on his novel, and they can enjoy their perfect life together, except that things are not perfect.
John soon finds himself focusing only on his novel, pretty much ignoring Maggie and their family, and before you can say “Jack Torrance,” Maggie finds herself wondering if perhaps her marriage to John has been a mistake.
If this plot sounds rather serious and sad, that’s because it is. However, that’s not to say the film isn’t funny. It has its moments. There’s a light tone throughout, and the characters are quirky enough to keep things lively. Just don’t expect to be laughing out loud.
The best part of MAGGIE’S PLAN are the characters and what their story has to say about relationships. The acting’s not so bad, either!
I thoroughly enjoyed Greta Gerwig as Maggie.She makes Maggie such a sincere and well meaning character, you can’t help but like her. She also possesses an adorable innocence about her. At one point, Georgette questions Maggie’s personality and wonders if there isn’t something just plain stupid about her, but Maggie isn’t stupid. She just wants to do right by people. The trouble is, the more she tries, the worst things get.
Take her first plan, for instance, where her geeky math friend Guy agrees to provide her with his sperm. The two characters are each so quirky you can’t help but chuckle when they’re on screen together, but the story keeps you from laughing out loud because it’s obvious that Guy likes Maggie a lot and wants to be more involved with her, yet he’s too awkward to do anything about it. When he asks Maggie how much involvement she expects from him, she answers, “I was going to say none.” She then offers to change her mind if he feels otherwise about it, but all Guy can muster is “None. Yeah. That’s great.”
Within seconds of seeing Maggie and John married on screen, it’s clear that there is trouble in paradise. Gerwig does a terrific job showing us Maggie’s internalizations, and when she realizes that their marriage is doomed, that perhaps John really does belong back with Georgette, and she approaches the icy Georgette with a proposition, it doesn’t come off as manipulative or calculating, but completely sincere. Of course, Georgette doesn’t agree.
Yet, later, when the two characters find themselves liking each other, it plays out in a perfectly natural fashion.
Julianne Moore has an absolute field day as Georgette. She’s never been icier. As you would expect, Moore lifts the role above the cliche as she makes this seemingly cold-hearted character someone you actually like.
Only Ethan Hawke struggles to connect as professor-wannabe-author John, and he stands out because nearly every other character in the film does connect. Part of it is John is something of a self-absorbed cold fish. I understand why both Georgette and Maggie want to be with him. For Maggie, she’s initially enthralled by his intellect and she feels she can save him from his wife and empower him in his life. Georgette loves him because he defers to her dominance and supports her every move. Yet, she’s smart enough to realize later in the movie that she was too selfish with him and should have been thinking about his needs.
But as a character, John is wishy-washy and noncommital, seemingly changing his mind every time the wind blows. He’s a difficult character to like. Yet Hawke does make him sympathetic-finally near the end- when he correctly realizes he’s being manipulated and doesn’t like it all that much.
The supporting cast is a good one and provides the film with its quirkiest characters and moments. Bill Hader and Maya Rudolph as Maggie’s husband and wife friends Tony and Felicia come closest to being straight out funny. Tony is brutally blunt, and generally has Maggie’s best interests in mind, even though she doesn’t always want to hear it. Maya Rudolph’s Felicia calmly and drolly puts up with her husband’s outspoken antics, and she’s more than capable and comfortable putting him in his place.Both Hader and Rudolph are alumns of SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE.
Travis Fimmel is charming in an oddball geeky sort of way as Guy, Maggie’s math genius turned pickle entrepeneur who’s ready to donate his sperm to her, and like Maggie, his character exudes raw honesty to the point where he seems a bit dumb, although like Maggie, he’s anything but.
The screenplay by director Rebecca Miller, based on a story by Karen Rinaldi, works more as a quirky drama than a comedy because the story is seeped with honesty and pain. The characters in this movie are not calculating and cold-hearted, although Maggie likes to plan and Georgette has ice in her veins, but both characters come off as three dimensional and genuine.
Even when some scenes enter into comedy, laughter is difficult to come by because of the sincere tones of sadness underneath.
That’s not to say there aren’t funny moments in the movie. The sequence where Maggie tries to inseminate herself is nicely paced as it goes from slightly awkward to full blown embarrassing.
And in a near perfect moment, it’s both ironic and telling that the liveliest and perhaps only laugh-out-loud moment in the movie comes when John and Georgette find themselves stranded together in a lodge in snowy Canada. It’s ironic because Maggie is the liveliest character in the film, yet for the movie’s liveliest moment, she’s absent, and it’s telling because it’s what’s true about Maggie’s life: she’s always trying to help, but things tend to work best when she’s simply out of the way.
Subtlety reigns throughout MAGGIE’S PLAN, and as such, you won’t find yourself laughing too much. But that won’t stop you from enjoying this low-key tale of a love triangle that never seems to go as planned.