
With the passing of Patrick Stewart this past week, the venerable actor has been on my mind, and so this week on our MOVIE LISTS column, we’ll have a look-see at the STAR TREK: NEXT GENERATION movies, where, as he did on the NEXT GENERATION TV show (1987-1994) and more recently on the TV series STAR TREK: PICARD (2020-2023), he played Captain Jean Luc Picard.
I’ve been a lifelong STAR TREK fan, and my adoration for the series precedes Stewart and THE NEXT GENERATION, as I was a fan of the original STAR TREK series first, which starred William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy, and DeForest Kelley. As such, I’ve always preferred Shatner’s Captain Kirk to Stewart’s Captain Picard.
In fact, when the NEXT GENERATION series premiered in 1987, I didn’t even watch it, as I felt, as did many other Star Trek fans, that a second show with new characters was doomed for failure. But it didn’t take long for word of mouth to spread the news that this show was actually pretty decent, and it wasn’t long after that I did start to watch it and eventually enjoy it immeasurably. In fact, a lot of the episodes outdid in quality many of the episodes from the original series.
And I grew to really like Captain Picard, as played by Patrick Stewart. So much so, that while I still prefer Shatner’s Captain Kirk, the preference is only by the width of a string on a Vulcan lyre. I ended up being a huge fan of the show and was saddened when it eventually ended.
But the show’s absence was short-lived because later that same year Picard and his fellow crewmembers made the jump from TV to the big screen with their first STAR TREK movie.
Now, the six STAR TREK movies featuring William Shatner and his fellow crew of actors from the original series, while deviating in quality, were all very entertaining and for the most part, on par with the quality of the original series. On the other hand, the NEXT GENERATION movies never quite captured the magic of their TV show, and as such, were cinematic and box office disappointments.
There were four STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION movies. First up:
STAR TREK: GENERATIONS (1994)
By far, this is my least favorite of the Next Generation Star Trek movies. It was an attempt to mix both Star Trek series together, an admirable idea, but the execution of this noble undertaking was a complete fail. If you’re going to bring the casts together, do it completely, not in the tepid way it is done in this movie, which is really only about having Captain Kirk and Captain Picard meet, again, a noble idea, but ridiciously, their meeting at the end is the worst part of the entire movie.
It opens well, with an early sequence featuring William Shatner as Captain Kirk, along with original characters Scotty (James Doohan) and Chekov (Walter Koenig) in a scene which supposedly shows us the death of Captain Kirk as he saves the ship. Hmm, where have we seen this before? (WRATH OF KHAN, anyone?)
The action jumps to the future with the NEXT GENERATION cast, and the story told here is largely forgettable. The key component is a thing called the Nexus, which plays fast and loose with the space time continuum, and it’s here where Picard (Patrick Stewart) meets Captain Kirk (William Shatner) and the two combine forces to defeat the movie’s villain, Soran (Malcolm McDowell). But these scenes of the two captains are laughably bad, thanks to some awful writing, and Captain Kirk’s ultimate death is contrived and forced and completely inferior to the cinematic death of Mr. Spock in WRATH OF KHAN. It’s a terrible send off for the penultimate Star Trek character. Sadly, not even the combined presence of Patrick Stewart and William Shatner could come close to saving this movie.
STAR TREK: FIRST CONTACT (1996)
And quickly we move from the worst NEXT GENERATION movie to the best, as by far, STAR TREK: FIRST CONTACT is the best of the NEXT GENERATION movies. It should come as no surprise, then, that Patrick Stewart’s best big screen performance as Picard comes right here in this movie.
The plot features the most notable villains from the series, the Borg, and since Picard has scars from when he was abducted by the Borg and turned into a cyborg, the plot of this one hits his character hard and as such, it’s a deep emotional performance by Stewart. Unfortunately, it’s only half the movie, as the other half focuses on a back-in-time visit to Earth where we meet Zefram Cochran (James Cromwell) the man responsible for establishing first contact with the Vulcans.
Still, this Star Trek adventure directed by Jonathan Frakes is highly entertaining and exciting, and features the best Patrick Stewart as Captain Picard performance in the movies.
STAR TREK: INSURRECTION (1998)
A decent STAR TREK adventure that is sadly terribly boring. It plays out like a slow episode from the series, which in a TV series, you’re allowed to have a slow episode here and there. But in a movie? Why bother! It’s got to be the best story out there, or else why make it? Again. Patrick Stewart turns in an exceptional performance as Captain Picard, and as dull as this movie is, I’ve always enjoyed it, mostly because I enjoy Patrick Stewart’s performance.
STAR TREK: NEMESIS (2002)
The final NEXT GENERATION movie, and the first STAR TREK film to be rated PG-13 as opposed to PG, has a neat idea for a story but then drops the ball with it. This one is about a clone of Picard, played by Tom Hardy, who is leading the Romulans in an effort to destroy the Federation. Once more, this movie is done in by sloppy writing and contrived ideas and situations. I’ve always wanted to like this one, but it always leaves me disappointed.
So, all in all, the NEXT GENERATION movies really aren’t all that good. The biggest problem is nothing in these films is as good or as of high quality as what we saw on the NEXT GENERATION TV show. Patrick Stewart, as you would expect, is decent in all four movies, with his best performances coming in the middle two, but if you really want to see Stewart excel as Captain Picard, you have to watch the TV shows, both NEXT GENERATION and STAR TREK: PICARD.
There you have it. A brief look at the four STAR TREK: NEXT GENERATION movies, inspired by thoughts of Patrick Stewart, as we honor his passing.
-END-








