
Wow, that’s a whale of a problem!
Imagine getting stuck inside a 60-ton sperm whale! How does one get out of that predicament?
Honestly, when I heard of this plot point in WHALEFALL (2026), I couldn’t help but think, you can’t be serious? Is this a comedy or something? Wouldn’t someone swallowed up by a whale just be dead? How would they survive?
But WHALEFALL is anything but a comedy. I wish I could say it’s an intense edge-of-your-seat thriller, but sadly, it’s not, and “sadly” is the operative word here, because if there’s one thing WHALEFALL is throughout its one hour and 46 minutes running time, is sad and depressing. So much so, that I was distracted throughout and never really got on board with the story this one was telling.
WHALEFALL wastes no time playing its sadness card, as in the very first scene we witness a sickly on-his-deathbed Mitt Gardiner (Josh Brolin) on his boat with his best buddy, and it’s clear that Mitt has little time left. He peeks at letters he has left his family, and then he dives off the boat to his death.
We then meet his family, his wife, adult daughters, and his college-aged, estranged son, Jay (Austin Abrams), who unfortunately had a very tumultuous relationship with his dad. In fact, he moved from California to Iowa to go to college mostly because he wanted to get away from his father. Yet, he always wanted to please his dad, and so he goes off on a dive on his own to locate his father’s body, and it’s here he gets in the middle of a battle between a sperm whale and a giant squid, and along with the squid, he gets swallowed up by the whale. And while inside the whale, he hears the voice of his dad, who guides him to survival.
So, there’s your story.
Honestly, I was really intrigued to see this movie, because I was really curious as to how someone could survive inside a whale, and I expected a pretty intense movie. Unfortunately, WHALEFALL offers no insights into how a human could sruvive inside a whale or any background information on whales at all, other than Josh Brolin’s Mitt character- who we see and hear from quite a bit in flashbacks- going on and on about his own philosophical thoughts on whales and the creatures’ place in nature. I really thought the screenplay dropped the ball here.
It also dropped the ball with the emotions, as this one is so steeped in sadness and depression it just lost me. I get the point. Jay and his dad struggled to get along. They both wanted to get along. And in spite of how badly his dad treated him, Jay still loved his dad, dives into the ocean to find his dad, and once inside the whale, relies on hearing the voice of his dad to survive, and the two have a reconciliation after Mitt is dead. I get all this.
The problem is in those flashback scenes, we see Mitt treat Jay so horribly, it’s to the point where I’m asking, why are we even seeing a story built around this guy? Sure, he was aware that he was being too harsh on his son, but so what? It didn’t change the way he treated him. We witness Jay enduring such emotional angst at the hands of his dad, it’s pretty much abusive. So, this whole storyline just lost me. I didn’t care about Mitt at all, and I couldn’t help but think Jay would be better off without him.
The screenplay is also completely devoid of humor, which comes as a surprise, because director Brian Duffield wrote the screenplay, based on a book by Daniel Kraus, and Duffield previously wrote the screenplay for the lively horror movie THE BABYSITTER (2017), a film that was full of humor and was quite funny.
Actors Austin Abrams and Josh Brolin are reunited following their pairing in Zach Cregger’s WEAPONS (2025). Speaking of Cregger, we just saw Austin Abrams in the lead role in Cregger’s RESIDENT EVIL (2026), a horror movie that was incredibly funny. Humor goes a long way, and it is sorely missing from the proceedings here in WHALEFALL. It even affects the performances.
Austin Abrams was so much fun to watch in RESIDENT EVIL, but he’s sad beyond belief here in WHALEFALL. Likewise, Josh Brolin’s performance makes Mitt a guy I just wouldn’t want to know.
Even with a decent supporting cast, which includes Elisabeth Shue and John Ortiz, the acting, like the rest of the movie, is a downer.
I also wasn’t impressed by Brian Duffield’s directorial effort. The scenes inside the whale should have been exceedingly intense and exciting, but they’re not. There are a couple of decent sequences, like when Jay is tangling with the squid which like Jay is still alive inside the whale, but so much of the camerawork takes place up close, you don’t really get a feel for what Jay is going through. I get it, as it is supposed to capture a claustrophobic feeling, and it does do this up to a point, but the camera never pulls back enough to give the audience a feel for what it is like inside that whale. Most of the shots are all close ups of Jay’s face.
The CGI effects are also nothing to write home about. Obviously, the filmmakers here didn’t shoot “on location” inside a whale’s body, and pretty much everything we see in this interior setting, as well as shots of the whale itself, never reach the level of no doubt believability.
It also doesn’t help that every time things do get a tad intense, Duffield “treats’ us to another flashback, where we have to suffer through another scene where Mitt torments his son. Even the “dad knew what he was talking about” reveals late in the movie, where Jay remembers things his dad said to him, and uses them to survive, fall flat, because as I said, Mitt is such an abhorrent character.
Yet, I was mildly intrigued throughout this one, mostly because it’s not every day you see a story about a guy trying to survive while inside a whale. That being said, “mildly” intrigued is a disappointment, because there’s nothing “mild” about a human being trying to survive after being swallowed up by a whale.
This one should have been much better.
I give it two stars.
-END-
RATING SYSTEM
Four stars – Perfect, Top of the line
Three and a half stars- Excellent
Three stars – Very Good
Two and a half stars – Good
Two Stars – Fair
One and a half stars – Pretty Weak
One star- Poor
Zero stars – Awful













