
When you lie all the time, how can you be trusted?
That’s just one of the themes in WILD HORSE NINE (2026), the latest movie by writer/director Martin McDonagh, the man who brought us THE BANSHEES OF INISHERIN (2022) and THREE BILLBOARDS OUTSIDE EBBING, MISSOURI (2017). The film also features two outstanding performances by John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell, and in Malkovich’s case, it’s one of the best performances of his long career.
It’s 1973, and two CIA agents, Chris (John Malkovich) and Lee (Sam Rockwell) leave Santiago, Chile, for a week’s respite on Easter Island to see the “big heads” there. Chris is a self-proclaimed perpetual liar. He lies all the time and can’t help it. On the other hand, he is a CIA agent, so how much of his lying is a personality flaw or simply on purpose is anyone’s guess. He’s also, according to Lee, a big pain in the butt, because he’s always running off his mouth and saying things that can get them in hot water, like one scene early on where he tells two women at an airport that he and Lee are CIA and pretty much gives away their mission, to which Lee has to respond that “of course they aren’t CIA” and implies to the women that Chris is a bit crazy.
We also learn that Chris is dying from cancer, and only has days to live, and he has chosen Easter Island, a faraway peaceful place with little police presence, so that his friend Lee can shoot him in the head and end his existence peacefully. He made this choice to end his life on his own terms. Or did he?
It comes to light that the higher ups at the CIA, especially Chris and Lee’s boss MJ (Steve Buscemi) are worried about Chris because of his alleged involvement in the Kennedy assassination. Chris is purportedly writing his memoirs, and MJ is afraid of what Chris will put in there regarding the assassination, and so he wants Lee to steal the recordings Chris is making and also to eliminate Chris, who also struggles with a faulty memory, and so he doesn’t always remember what he has said, and he has to write himself notes to remember things, and one written note he finds in his pocket says, “Don’t trust Lee.”
And while the basic plot remains intriguing and never disappoints, as the audience will be guessing who’s telling the truth, who’s lying, who is to be trusted, and just what will happen between Chris and Lee, the best part of WILD HORSE NINE by far is one, the snappy and hilarious dialogue by screenwriter/director Martin McDonagh— there are laugh out loud moments throughout this one— and two, a possibly career best performance by John Malkovich.
Malkovich is absolutely terrific here as Chris. While he says he’s a liar, he’s also incredibly blunt and truthful, and his reflections on life, as he looks back, are both poignant and hilarious. Chris is a man who just wants to live longer and keep embracing life for as long as he can, while looking back and wishing, as he says, that he didn’t kill as many people as he did, but sometimes again as he says, you have to do bad things for the greater good. Malkovich has made so many movies over the years, and has played many memorable roles, from way back when in DANGEROUS LIAISONS (1988), to IN THE LINE OF FIRE (1993) to the horror movie BIRD BOX (2018), but his work here in WILD HORSE NINE is among his best performances.
Sam Rockwell is one of my favorite actors working today, and he’s also excellent here as Lee, and he lies about as much as Chris does. We see Lee as always trying to prevent Chris from getting them into trouble. The two share a genuine friendship, and so the intriguing question throughout the movie is, is it true that Lee would kill Chris on orders from his superiors, or is it true that this was just Chris’ request? The movie does not let the audience down with its answers.
Parker Posey also enjoys a scene-stealing performance in a supporting role as Lee’s unfaithful wife, who drinks regularly and has numerous extramarital affairs, both of which she says happen because of the stress of being married to Lee.
It’s an exceptional and layered screenplay by McDonagh. It speaks to friendship, to the manipulations of governments by other governments, and it tackles all of these rather dark themes in a wickedly witty screenplay. And things get really dark when Chris explains to his young woman friend from Santiago, that if she really wants to make a difference, she has to either become violent and kill those who would do her harm or hide away on some deserted island away from it all. In Chris’ view, based on everything he has seen over the years, the world is that bad.
Chris has a great line when he calls his estranged brother to let him know he only has days to live, and his brother chastises him saying he never should have killed JFK, because the world went to sh*t afterwards, to which Chris replies, the world was already sh*t. It’s just that people didn’t know it. In this same conversation there’s also a key clue which explains the answer regarding who’s choice it was to come to Easter Island, Chris or Lee’s.
As he did in THE BANSHEES OF INISHERON, McDonagh also includes a key relationship between a main character and an animal. In BANSHEES, it was Colin Farrell’s character with a donkey, and here, it’s Malkovich’s Chris with a wild horse. The scenes the two share with each other are among the best in the movie.
And as he did as a director with BANSHEES, capturing the beauty of an Irish island, McDonagh does the same here with wonderful cinematography of Easter Island.
I really enjoyed WILD HORSE NINE. It has two exceptional performances by John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell, and a brilliant oftentimes hilarious screenplay by Martin McDonagh, that at times is as sad and as poignant as it is funny, and it is never dull.
This film fires on all cylinders from start to finish.
WILD HORSE NINE easily earns four stars.
-END-
RATING SYSTEM
Four stars – Perfect, Top of the line
Three and a half stars- Excellent
Three stars – Very Good
Two and a half stars – Good
Two Stars – Fair
One and a half stars – Pretty Weak
One star- Poor
Zero stars – Awful








