
Excuse me, where’s the monster with all the bandages?
Ohhh, this isn’t OTHER MUMMY? It’s OTHER MOMMY. I see.
You know, there are some movie titles that just don’t do the movie any favors. I’m sorry, but OTHER MOMMY? It has ridiculousness written all over it. I crack up every time I see it. It sounds like a bad sitcom.
Anyway, the title is the least of this one’s problems.
OTHER MOMMY (2026) is a new horror movie by director Rob Savage, the man who brought us THE BOOGEYMAN (2023) a few years back, a rather lame horror movie that didn’t work all that well for me. OTHER MOMMY is worse, unfortunately.
There’s a good story in there somewhere, and that’s because the screenplay by Nathan Elston is based on the novel Incidents Around the House by Josh Malerman, and so once again here we have an example of superior source material done in my a muddled screenplay.
In a nutshell, OTHER MOMMY is the story of an 8 year-old girl named Bela (Arabella Olivia Clark) whose imaginary friend takes on the image of her mother, and it isn’t just an imaginary friend, but an evil entity which wants to enter Bela’s heart in order to switch places with her. It wants to become human, and it wants to send Bela into the demon world. And it wants this because words superimposed on the screen before the opening credits inform the audience that human life is coveted by demons who desperately want to become human because being human is so precious. It is? Humans are awesome? I guess demons don’t watch the nightly news.
Anyway, once Bela’s parents, Mommy (Jessica Chastain) and Daddo (Jay Duplass) discover what’s going on and that their daughter is in danger, it’s up to them to protect her, something which in this movie they’re not very good at.
The movie even has a decent subtext, where the demon entices Bela that if she allows it to switch places with her, she’ll be safe and pain free, because in the real world, her heart is about to be broken by her parents, who are clearly having issues, and Bela sees this. And so, the demon’s offer begins to look better and better as the movie goes along, as Bela sees her parents approaching divorce mode.
This storyline is the best part of OTHER MOMMY. Unfortunately, the way director Rob Savage decides to tell this story, is the worst part.
Let’s start with how this one begins. We immediately meet the three central family members, and in a sequence given away in the movie’s trailers, we watch Bela have an uncomfortable encounter with her “other mommy” before Daddo (who comes up with these names?) rushes in when there’s a fire on top of the stove. As Daddo comforts Bela, he sees the Other Mommy with her body bizarrely contorted and as he screams aloud in fright, the title sequence blares out OTHER MOMMY in a way that can only be described as over the top and comical. For a moment, I thought I was watching a parody.
The fact that the parents learn about Other Mommy immediately was somewhat refreshing. However, how they handle everything afterwards is ludicrous and unbelievable. They clearly win The Worst Movie Parents of the Year Award as they fail in everything they attempt to do to protect Bela.
This movie lost me from the moment those bizarre opening titles blasted onto the screen, and things only got worse.
The performances don’t help.
Jessica Chastain, a fine actress who has delivered many notable performances, plays the most annoying mother in a movie I’ve seen in a while. She’s cold and distant at first, clearly not happy in her marriage, clearly not happy being a mother, and then of course, late in the game, has a complete change of heart, a transition that is so unbelievable it makes one think the title of this one should have been FAKE MOMMY. Chastain has also starred in her share of genre movies, from IT: CHAPTER TWO (2019) to CRIMSON PEAK (2015). This is probably the first time I have ever not enjoyed a performance by Jessica Chastain.
Jay Duplass is even worse as Daddo. Most of the time the guy is excessively syrupy sweet- no wonder Mommy is no longer in love with him. He is supposed to be funny, but his humor misfires throughout. The screenplay doesn’t help. When things are at their bleakest, late in the game, he’s cracking jokes and throwing a party to “lighten the mood.” WTF? The biggest surprise in this one is why little Bela doesn’t say yes to the demon’s offer immediately! I can’t imagine being stuck in this family as a kid.
Scary? Nope. It seems director Rob Savage wouldn’t know a scary sequence if it bit him in the ass.
Chastain does do double duty here as she plays Other Mommy as well, but what constitutes as frightening for her are long cringy smiles and repeatedly asking, “Can I go into your heart?” before she gives way to ridiculous special effects. The only reaction the scare/gore effects in this one got from the audience I saw it with was laughter.
Karen Allen, famous for playing Marion in RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK (1981), plays Bela’s grandmother, but sadly, it’s yet another performance in this movie that doesn’t go anywhere.
The only positive about this movie is a nice performance by little Arabella Olivia Clark as Bela. She’s good, and that’s about the only thing that’s good about this one.
The ending, where it’s actually little Bela who takes charges, is also a letdown.
The entire movie is a letdown, mostly because there is so much potential here with a story about tempting a little girl to say yes to a demon because her parents are dysfunctional, but this movie can’t even get this right.
OTHER MOMMY is a snooze from start to finish.
As I sat there stuck in the theater suffering through this one, I couldn’t help but wish I was watching an OTHER MOVIE instead.
I give it one star.
-END-
RATING SYSTEM
Four stars – Perfect, Top of the line
Three and a half stars- Excellent
Three stars – Very Good
Two and a half stars – Good
Two Stars – Fair
One and a half stars – Pretty Weak
One star- Poor
Zero stars – Awful
















