I finally caught up with LATE NIGHT WITH THE DEVIL (2024), the horror movie which generated quite the buzz when it was released to theaters back in March. It was a very small release and didn’t play in my area, so I wasn’t able to catch it on the big screen.
I rented it this past weekend on Prime Video; it’s also available on the streaming service, Shudder.
LATE NIGHT WITH THE DEVIL tells the story of a fictional 1970s late night talk show struggling with ratings, and so in desperation, in a special Halloween night episode, the host, Jack Delroy (David Dastmalchian) invites a psychologist, June Ross-Mitchell (Laura Gordon) onto the show with her patient, a 13 year-old girl named Lilly (Ingrid Torelli) who had been rescued from a satanic cult and who says she has a demon residing within her. On live TV, Jack plans to have June lead a session where she contacts the demon inside Lilly in order to bring it onto the show.
The movie falls into the “found-footage” category, because after an eight-minute introduction, explaining Jack Delroy’s backstory and how it was that he ended up in this predicament, as a late-night talk show host constantly losing the ratings battle to Johnny Carson in spite of winning numerous awards, the movie pivots and explains that what is to follow is the complete footage of that historic Halloween episode, along with black and white behind the scenes footage taken during commercial breaks.
So, for the rest of the movie, we get to see what happened on that fateful night on October 31, 1977.
By far, my favorite part of LATE NIGHT WITH THE DEVIL was the work of brother directors Cameron Cairnes and Colin Cairnes. They recreate the look and feel of a 1970s late night TV show to perfection. The cinematography, the colors, the costumes, hairstyles, mannerisms, the whole kit and caboodle, all of it, is so authentically recreated that this alone is worth the price of admission. You watch this movie, and you can almost believe that this show existed and was giving Johnny Carson a run for his money.
The Cairnes brothers also wrote the screenplay, and for the most part, they create a very intriguing story. Host Jack Delroy’s backstory is somewhat mysterious and compelling, and the idea of a never-been-done-before live television event, the conjuring of a demon, is rather novel and plays out in captivating fashion. Midway through this movie I was glued to the screen, thanks to a combination of believable acting performances by all the principal players, authentic cinematography, and a story— this fictional controversial late night TV episode— that was refreshing and new.
Where this movie lost me was with its ending. The Cairnes brothers don’t quite close the deal. Everything up to the shocking demon conjuring works and works exceedingly well. But afterwards, when professional magician turned skeptic Carmichael Haig (Ian Bliss) attempts to debunk the proceedings, while interesting, takes a path that is ironically somewhat less believable than what came before it. And also unnecessary. He could have dispensed with the less believable theatrics and simply requested they watch the video of the demon conjuring which would have proved or disproved his point just the same.
And then what happens next as we watch Jack Delroy’s ultimate fate shows flashes of promise but follows a plot point hinted at earlier in the movie that is far less interesting than the main point of a TV show so desperate for ratings, they turn to summoning demons. It’s a letdown.
The cast, however, is very good, led by David Dastmalchian as Jack Delroy, who gives a brilliant and the best performance in the movie. Although a late night TV host, a persona he captures perfectly, he’s also a somber, dark person, haunted by the untimely death of his wife a year earlier. It’s a far cry from his humorous Polka-Dot Man in THE SUICIDE SQUAD (2021). Dastmalchian has been in a lot of movies, including to name just a few THE LAST VOYAGE OF THE DEMETER (2023), OPPENHEIMER (2023), the recent DUNE movies, and Marvel’s ANT-MAN movies.
Laura Gordon is solid as psychologist June Ross-Mitchell, and young Ingrid Torelli is unsettling as Lilly. Ian Bliss tends to ham it up a bit too much as pompous skeptic Carmichael Haig, but I enjoyed Rhys Auteri as long-suffering Jack Delroy sidekick Gus McConnell, who repeatedly tries and fails to get Jack to stop the show.
LATE NIGHT WITH THE DEVIL is a horror movie that works because its story is refreshing and original, and its execution in telling this story is flawless. However, it’s not as scary as it could be, and its story isn’t a complete winner because it doesn’t seal the deal, as it has an ending that deviates a bit from what made the rest of the movie so compelling, the episode itself. Throwing in more backstory on Jack at the end to give meaning to his motives was unnecessary. What matters most with this one is what all went down on the air on a Halloween night in 1977, and while that is being recreated on screen, the film soars.
As a result, I give LATE NIGHT WITH THE DEVIL two and a half stars.
—END—
RATING SYSTEM
Four stars – Perfect, Top of the line
Three and a half stars- Excellent
Three stars – Very Good
Two and a half stars – Good
Two Stars – Fair
One and a half stars – Pretty Weak
One star- Poor
Zero stars – Awful